Pope Questions ‘Just War’ Doctrine

INTRODUCTION

Pope Francis’ new encyclical spends only six paragraphs on the Church’s doctrine on ‘just war,’ but Fratelli Tutti might have upended the entire teaching on the subject.

WRITTEN BY

SHARE THE WORD

PUBLISHED ON

“We can no longer think of war as a solution because its risks will probably always be greater than its supposed benefits. In view of this, it is very difficult nowadays to invoke the rational criteria elaborated in earlier centuries to speak of the possibility of a ‘just war.’ Never again war!” Francis writes.

The pope notes that the Catechism of the Catholic Church speaks of the possibility of legitimate defense by means of military force, as long as “rigorous conditions of moral legitimacy” have been met, yet he warns it is “easy to fall into an overly broad interpretation of this potential right,” noting that in recent decades every war was presented by its instigators as a ‘just war.’

“While Francis does not repudiate in an absolute way the ‘just war’ theory in Fratelli Tutti, he does continue down a path that the church has been heading since the pontificate of John XXIII, and followed by all of his successors in one way or another,” said Daniel Cosacchi, the Director of the Justice and Peace Studies Program at Marywood University in Scranton, Pennsylvania.

Francis is laying out the ways to build peace throughout Fratelli Tutti, and the passages on ‘just war’ can’t be read in isolation, told Crux Dr. Maryann Cusimano Love, Associate Professor of International Relations in the Politics Department of The Catholic University of America in Washington. “He’s laying out how you do reconciliation and forgiveness,” she said

Moving Away From ‘Just War’
“He refers to ‘peace’ about 125 times throughout the document, he refers to ‘just war’ tradition only twice,” Cusimano Love said. “The Church teaching has been moving away from ‘just war’ tradition for many decades now…but there’s a lot of people who don’t want to hear this message,” she said.

Peter Koritansky, Associate Professor of Philosophy and Religion at the University of Prince Edward Island, said it would be “problematic” to suggest that war was “intrinsically evil” in the Catholic tradition.

“To suggest that war is intrinsically evil would mean that God, in commanding the chosen people to take up arms, commanded them to commit intrinsically evil actions. Similarly, such a suggestion would be contrary to the teaching of the Church, which has clearly opted for a ‘just war’ doctrine over a pacifistic one,” he told Crux.

“For these reasons, I think it’s far preferable to say that the Holy Father’s remarks should be seen as reapplying the Church’s teaching due to changing circumstances rather than altering it, which is what the ‘intrinsic evil’ interpretation would constitute,” he added.

Koritansky said that on the face of it, the implication in Fratelli Tutti is that war is more difficult to justify morally in the contemporary world than it was in the past.

“But what precisely is it about the contemporary world that explains the added difficulty? One suggestion in the document is the advent of modern weaponry, especially nuclear and chemical weapons. If this is what he means, the point is well taken. The devastation caused by nuclear weapons drastically changes the calculation of whether to go to war,” he said.

St. Augustine 
Footnote 242 of Fratelli Tutti says: “Saint Augustine, who forged a concept of ‘just war’ that we no longer uphold in our day, also said that ‘it is a higher glory still to stay war itself with a word than to slay men with the sword, and to procure or maintain peace by peace, not by war.’”

“This came as a shock to me,” said Cosacchi. “Saint Augustine is usually considered to be the ‘founder’ or ‘father’ of the ‘just war’ theory (along with his mentor, St. Ambrose). There are three essential parts to the Augustinian ‘just war’ theory: 1) War is a response to an unjust aggressor; 2) a competent authority declares the war; 3) Augustine is concerned with just conduct during the war itself,” he explained.

“Now, these three beliefs are really the foundation for so much that has come after Augustine in the Church’s ‘just war’ theory … So, obviously the church has moved past the same understanding of war that Augustine had in the 4th century, but they have built on his understanding rather than abrogated it. To say, as Pope Francis does, ‘that we no longer uphold’ … it makes this footnote pave the way more than anything else, to a situation where the church will eventually move beyond a ‘just war’ theory at all,” Cosacchi said.

However, Koritansky says it would be a mistake to suggest that Francis “is merely disposing” of Augustine’s ‘just war’ teaching. “One could interpret the Holy Father’s words in one of two ways: First, one could read them to mean that the very concept of a ‘just war’ is now something the Church rejects. Second, one could interpret him to mean that the concept of a ‘just war’, perfectly valid as a concept, is much more difficult to apply to today’s world.

The first has the advantage of reflecting the ordinary meaning of the Holy Father’s actual word choice in this footnote. The second has the advantage of preserving the Holy Father from contradicting sacred tradition,” he said.

Koritansky also has a complaint about the “ambiguity” in the pope’s statements on ‘just war’ in the document. One unclear issue is what would be considered a “war”. For instance, the pope speaks positively about the role of the United Nations in Fratelli Tutti. Would a UN peacekeeping operation or even a UN police action fall under the category?

“Such distinctions are very important. Peacekeeping, as nowadays understood by the international community, does not at all seem to be what Pope Francis has in mind in his condemnation of ‘war’,” Koritansky told Crux.

Others Are Less Convinced
Jesuit Father Drew Christiansen –a senior fellow at the Berkley Center for Religion, Peace, and World Affairs–told Crux that the first thing that grabbed him was that Francis said that although “in principle, you may support humanitarian intervention, even with military means, but in practice, it’s too often made of use for going to war.”

Cosacchi said it seems UN interventions “could be justified according to Francis, especially if it is based in nonviolence and does not incite further violence on the part of the engaged parties in the conflict.”

He noted that when the pope visited South Korea in 2014, he said it was “licit to stop an unjust aggressor,” but added: “I underline the verb: stop. I do not say bomb, make war, I say stop by some means. With what means can they be stopped? These have to be evaluated.”

Cosacchi pointed out the pope then said the UN is the place where such responses ought to be discussed. “That is definitely an approach that he would prefer in such difficult situations,” he said.

Death Penalty
In the 1995 encyclical Evangelium Vitae, John Paul said the use of the justifications for the use of the death penalty in modern society “are very rare, if not practically non-existent.” In 2018, Francis took this to the next level, changing the Catechism to say capital punishment is “inadmissible.”

Cosacchi notes that Francis groups the death penalty and war together in Fratelli Tutti, pointing out that Francis believes that “everything is connected.” “The issues of war and the death penalty are the low-hanging fruit for him,” he said.

“He explains basically three reasons to study these two items together: 1) They are extreme situations; 2) They are false answers that fail at what they were meant to do; 3) All they ever accomplish is making the spiral of violence worse,” Cosacchi added.

“In response to those hoping for theologically precise language, and especially the question as to whether war and the death penalty are ‘intrinsically evil,’ the Holy Father cautions us not to become ‘mired in theoretical discussions,’” Koritansky said.

Cosacchi said Francis is preparing the ground for his successor to make a more definitive judgment on the legitimacy of war. “Just as John Paul II did in 1995 by seriously limiting the cases in which the death penalty would be justified, Pope Francis has made a similar point here about justified warfare. However, just as it took a future pope (Francis) to declare the death penalty inadmissible, it does seem as though Francis is saying that a future pope would make the same claim about justified warfare,” he said.  Published in Crux

Share Your Thoughts

All comments are moderated

From The Same Issue

The articles and content about this issue

From The Same Issue

The articles and content about this issue

From This Topic

The articles and content about this topic

From This Topic

The articles and content about this topic

WM Special

The three little shepherds

Explore Other Topics

Browse other coverage

Explore Other Topics

Browse other coverage

WM SPECIAL

Presents, discusses and draws readers to reflect on issues of outmost relevance to the world today.


FRONTIERS

Very often, mission is carried out in frontier situations around the world. Those who embrace these situations have much to share.


UNITY IN DIVERSITY

Writer Ilsa Reyes will be exploring the richness of Pope Francis’s latest encyclical Fratelli Tutti with a view of helping our readers to get a grasp of the this beautiful papal document.


FRONTLINE

Puts to the front committed and inspiring people around the world who embrace humanitarian and religious causes with altruism and passion.


IN FOCUS

Focus on a given theme of interest touching upon social, economic and religious issues.


FAITH@50

As the Philippines prepares to celebrate 500 years of the arrival of Christianity. Fr. James Kroeger leads us in this series into a discovery journey of the landmark events in the history of faith in the Philippine archipelago.


INSIGHT

Aims to nurture and inspire our hearts and minds while pondering upon timely themes.


FILIPINO FOCUS

The large archipelago of the Philippines, in its richness of peoples and cultures, offers varied and challenging situations for mission.


FOLLOW ME

Reflections and vocation stories that shape up the lives of young people.


MISSION IS FUN

As humor and goodness of heart are qualities of Christian and missionary life, the new column “Mission is fun” will be publishing some anecdotes and stories that have happened in a missionary context to lighten up the spirits and trigger a smile in our faces.


LIVING COMMUNION

To help readers of World Mission live this year dedicated to Ecumenism, Interreligious Dialogue and Indigenous Peoples, Tita Puangco, writer and lecturer, shares in this section insights on the spirituality of communion.


WINDS OF THE SPIRIT

A historic view of the Catholic movements that emerged from the grassroots as an inspiration by the Holy Spirit.


BRIDGE BUILDERS

On the Year of Ecumenism, Interreligious Dialogue and Indigenous Peoples, radio host and communicator Ilsa Reyes, in her monthly column, encourages Christians and people of good will to be one with their fellow people of other sects, religions and tribes.


INTERVIEW

Questions to a personality of the Church or secular world on matters of interest that touch upon the lives of people.


WORLD TOUCH

News from the Church, the missionary world and environment that inform and form the consciences.


CARE OF THE EARTH

A feature on environmental issues that are affecting the whole world with the view of raising awareness and prompting action.


EDITORIAL

The editor gives his personal take on a given topic related to the life of the Church, the society or the world.


YOUNG HEART

A monthly column on themes touching the lives of young people in the Year of the Youth in the Philippines by radio host and communicator I lsa Reyes.


SCROLL

A missionary living in the Chinese world shares his life-experiences made up of challenges and joyous encounters with common people.


EXTRAORDINARY PEOPLE

Life stories of people who deserve to be known for who they were, what they did and what they stood for in their journey on earth.


ONE BY ONE

Stories of people whom a missionary met in his life and who were touched by Jesus in mysterious ways.


INCREASE OUR FAITH

Critical reflection from a Christian perspective on current issues.


SPECIAL MOMENTS

Comboni missionary Fr. Lorenzo Carraro makes a journey through history pinpointing landmark events that changed the course of humanity.


PROFILE

A biographical sketch of a public person, known for his/her influence in the society and in the Church, showing an exemplary commitment to the service of others.


WM REPORTS

Gives fresh, truthful, and comprehensive information on issues that are of concern to all.


LIFE'S ESSENTIALS

A column aimed at helping the readers live their Christian mission by focusing on what is essential in life and what it entails.


ASIAN FOCUS

Peoples, events, religion, culture and the society of Asia in focus.


THE SEARCHER'S PATH

The human heart always searches for greatness in God’s eyes, treading the path to the fullness of life - no matter what it takes.


INDIAN FOCUS

The subcontinent of India with its richness and variety of cultures and religions is given center stage.


AFRICAN FOCUS

The African continent in focus where Christianity is growing the fastest in the world.


JOURNEY MOMENTS

Well-known writer and public speaker, Fr. Jerry Orbos, accompanies our journey of life and faith with moments of wit and inspiration based on the biblical and human wisdom.


IGNATIUS STEPS

On the year dedicated to St. Ignatius of Loyala, Fr. Lorenzo Carraro walks us through the main themes of the Ignatian spirituality.


THE SEVEN LAST WORDS OF JESUS

Fr. John Taneburgo helps us to meditate every month on each of the Seven Last Words that Jesus uttered from the cross.


INSIDE THE HOLY BOOK

In this section, Fr. Lorenzo delves into the secrets and depths of the Sacred Scriptures opening for us the treasures of the Sacred Book so that the reader may delight in the knowledge of the Word of God.


CONVERSATIONS

Reflections about the synodal journey on a conversational and informal style to trigger reflection and sharing about the synodal path the Church has embarked upon.

Shopping Cart