Mary and Female Deities of East Asia

INTRODUCTION

Catholics venerated female deities associated with Buddhism and with Chinese popular religion in different contexts as one way to express their Marian devotions.

WRITTEN BY

SHARE THE WORD

PUBLISHED ON

This second article explores how Marian devotions speak about Christian-Buddhist encounters in East Asia. The point is not to discuss an abstract theological dialogue between two major religious traditions. Rather, this article looks at how female deities associated with Buddhism (the bodhisattva Guanyin) and Chinese popular religion (the figure of Mazu in Taiwan) coexist with Marian devotions. What does it tell us about Mary and the Buddhist-Christian dialogue?

Most people have heard about Maria Kannon. This Japanese representation of the Virgin Mary emerged during the anti-Christian persecutions of the Edo period (1603-1868). To prevent punishment and possible death, Mary was represented through the appearance of the Bodhisattva Guanyin, a female Buddhist figure of universal compassion holding a child.

Marian devotees venerated these statues of Maria Kannon to give the impression that they were proper Buddhist devotees. However, a few elements on these statues indicate the Christian affiliation of the figurine. For two centuries, these porcelain artifacts were mostly produced in Southern China and sailed into Southern Japan. They later became a symbol of Christian suffering and resistance.

Yet, recent research shows that this kind of Marian-Buddhist hybridity is not an exception specific to Edo Japan. In fact, this is a long-term and resilient pattern of East Asian encounters between Christianity and Buddhism. It is a story of political persecution and resistance, a religious encounter, and proximity. To show that, I briefly summarize three pieces of research presented by scholars during the conference “More Universal than Catholicism? Mary Among Asian Religions” and further discuss the silent interreligious journey mediated through Marian devotions.

CHINESE PAINTINGS

Historians Song Gang and Wang Xintong analyze two hanging scroll paintings of Guanyin allegedly produced by the mid-Ming artist Tang Yin (1470–1524). By comparing their stylish features, iconographic symbolisms, and localized adaptations, they argue that these paintings are hidden representations of the Virgin Mary produced during the anti-Christian ban of the Chinese during the Qing dynasty (18th century) and purposefully attributed to Tang Yin to avoid political scrutiny. Like in Japan during the Edo period, Buddhism became a resource for persecuted Christians to continue their religious practices. Chinese Catholics strategically integrated Marian devotions into their local religious and artistic traditions to preserve their faith.

KOREAN STATUES

Presbyterian theologian Mideum Hong analyzes the statues produced by Choi Jong-Tae, a Korean sculptor born in 1932 and a Catholic layman. Most of these statues are representations of Mary that are now commonly found in Catholic churches in South Korea. They are inspired by the Buddhist art that flourished in the Korean peninsula during the sixth century and remains visible inside the Seokguram Grotto.

Unlike sandstone and limestone which were widely used in Buddhist India and China, Korean artists used local granite. Sculptor Choi argues that this artistic style and material represent the traditional spirit of Korea. Elaborating on this Buddhist art from the sixth century, his granite-made statues are characterized by restrained lines and simplified body shapes. Mary has a round face and stands with her hands clasped together. Departing from Western depictions, her eyes are represented by horizontal lines to express a serene and contemplative expression.

However, these Korean representations of Mary must be put in dialogue with their broader context. For the past decades, a growing number of Koreans have come to consider that their traditional clothes stand as a key symbol to express their ethnic distinction. More people wear traditional outfits during weddings and special events. These clothes are mobilized to perform and reinforce national identity.

Similarly, representations of Mary wearing a hanbok, the traditional Korean dress, has become one way to enculturate Catholicism. However, images and statues of Mary wearing hanbok remain rather marginal. At home, Korean Catholics prefer Western-style depictions of Mary. In front of their churches, mostly curved granite statues represent the Mother of God.

The paradox is that, in practice, it is a Buddhist tradition mobilized to translate Korean representations of Mary. In contrast to Korean clothes, which cover the body from outside, Buddhist resources provide an alternative way to highlight the internal transformation of a spiritual journey and to transcend national boundaries.

TAIWANESE PILGRIMAGES

Linguist Brian Reynolds and anthropologist Marco Lazzarotti study how Mary has been localized in Taiwan through pilgrimages and highlight similarities between Catholic practices and Taiwanese popular religion. For instance, they examine a well-known recent apparition of Mary who helped five non-Catholic men who got lost during a hike in the island’s high mountains. Trapped on a steep slope for several hours, they saw a white shape coming to them and showing them the way to go. Although this phenomenon echoes numerous beliefs in ghosts, they recognized the Christian figure because of her similarity to a Marian statue placed on the mountaintop by missionaries. Later, they embraced Catholicism and had a statue of her erected on the site. Today, this site has become a popular place of pilgrimage.

Another example is the Marian pilgrimage organized by the bishops’ conference in 2008-2009 to mark the 150th year of the Church in Taiwan. In a way quite similar to practices surrounding the local deity Mazu, a Virgin Mary of Wanchin statue was carried across the entire island to visit every parish.

This pilgrimage of a statue sought to reinforce the cohesion of the Taiwanese dioceses and encourage Catholics to show their faith publicly. The researchers report that “the statue of the Virgin Mary was also welcomed by non-Christians as if it was a “Christian variant” of Mazu. As tradition dictates, many deities came out of their temples to welcome the visitor and pay homage to her.

In both cases, the Taiwanese translation of Mary elaborates on local religious beliefs and practices infused with Chinese and Buddhist traditions. In some sense, there is a Taiwanese way to territorialize the material yet the other-worldy presence of divine entities. Under different capacities, non-Christians, lay Catholics, and Catholic clergymen have been collaborating in this Taiwanese localization of Mary.

Nevertheless, as we look back at the three East Asian cases together–Chinese paintings, Korean statues, and Taiwanese pilgrimages–we see that Marian devotees are walking a very fine line to express the specificities of their religious icon. Korean, Chinese, and Taiwanese believers cultivate apparent proximities between Mary, Guanyin, and Mazu to deploy their socio-religious project.

Similarities between the three female figures can be useful to partially hide the ambiguities of Christian affiliation, as they can strengthen a spiritual agenda and a national identity. Clearly, religious actors mobilize these apparent similarities to adjust their religious efforts to their specific time and place.

We must underscore, however, that if specific socio-political contexts and the flesh of religious practices matter, the underlying dialogue with non-Christian religions is essential to go beyond narrow nationalism and superficial piety. Mazu and Guanyin are mobilized to reveal the mystery of Mary, not secular figures.

Mary in East Asia is not simply Chinese, Korean, Taiwanese, or Western decoration. With the help of Asian religious traditions, her devotees highlight that she transcends time and space.

In dialogue with local deities, she overcomes national boundaries and fascination for the West. These subtle dynamics of Marian devotions in which we see the interplay between Christian and non-Christian spiritualities are important to overcome abstract and homogenizing discourses on Christian-Buddhist dialogue. In contemporary South Korea, Taiwan, and China, interreligious dialogue takes the very localized features of popular devotions to Mary.

At the same time, this interreligious proximity and the lack of obvious distinction between female deities can raise all sorts of concerns. The risk of syncretism and theological confusion is constantly raised by actors who want to deepen and purify their spiritual quest. These concerns are entirely valid and essential to consider.

When do we draw a line between fruitful proximity and dangerous syncretism? Based on our three case studies from East Asia, we see that cross-religious hybridities are not necessarily good or bad by nature. They happen in various contexts (not only during persecutions) and are used in various ways (not only to resist the majority).

Hybrid proximities can be promoted or rejected, reinforced or dismissed. The challenge is to identify the kind of context and power relation that make these perceptions shift. As a silent witness of our ecclesial struggles, Mary asks: who has the power to relabel dangerous syncretism into valuable enculturation? Why?

Share Your Thoughts

All comments are moderated

From The Same Issue

The articles and content about this issue

From The Same Issue

The articles and content about this issue

From This Topic

The articles and content about this topic

From This Topic

The articles and content about this topic

WM Special

The three little shepherds

WM Special

Still up in arms

Explore Other Topics

Browse other coverage

Explore Other Topics

Browse other coverage

WM SPECIAL

Presents, discusses and draws readers to reflect on issues of outmost relevance to the world today.


FRONTIERS

Very often, mission is carried out in frontier situations around the world. Those who embrace these situations have much to share.


UNITY IN DIVERSITY

Writer Ilsa Reyes will be exploring the richness of Pope Francis’s latest encyclical Fratelli Tutti with a view of helping our readers to get a grasp of the this beautiful papal document.


FRONTLINE

Puts to the front committed and inspiring people around the world who embrace humanitarian and religious causes with altruism and passion.


IN FOCUS

Focus on a given theme of interest touching upon social, economic and religious issues.


FAITH@50

As the Philippines prepares to celebrate 500 years of the arrival of Christianity. Fr. James Kroeger leads us in this series into a discovery journey of the landmark events in the history of faith in the Philippine archipelago.


INSIGHT

Aims to nurture and inspire our hearts and minds while pondering upon timely themes.


FILIPINO FOCUS

The large archipelago of the Philippines, in its richness of peoples and cultures, offers varied and challenging situations for mission.


FOLLOW ME

Reflections and vocation stories that shape up the lives of young people.


MISSION IS FUN

As humor and goodness of heart are qualities of Christian and missionary life, the new column “Mission is fun” will be publishing some anecdotes and stories that have happened in a missionary context to lighten up the spirits and trigger a smile in our faces.


LIVING COMMUNION

To help readers of World Mission live this year dedicated to Ecumenism, Interreligious Dialogue and Indigenous Peoples, Tita Puangco, writer and lecturer, shares in this section insights on the spirituality of communion.


WINDS OF THE SPIRIT

A historic view of the Catholic movements that emerged from the grassroots as an inspiration by the Holy Spirit.


BRIDGE BUILDERS

On the Year of Ecumenism, Interreligious Dialogue and Indigenous Peoples, radio host and communicator Ilsa Reyes, in her monthly column, encourages Christians and people of good will to be one with their fellow people of other sects, religions and tribes.


INTERVIEW

Questions to a personality of the Church or secular world on matters of interest that touch upon the lives of people.


WORLD TOUCH

News from the Church, the missionary world and environment that inform and form the consciences.


CARE OF THE EARTH

A feature on environmental issues that are affecting the whole world with the view of raising awareness and prompting action.


EDITORIAL

The editor gives his personal take on a given topic related to the life of the Church, the society or the world.


YOUNG HEART

A monthly column on themes touching the lives of young people in the Year of the Youth in the Philippines by radio host and communicator I lsa Reyes.


SCROLL

A missionary living in the Chinese world shares his life-experiences made up of challenges and joyous encounters with common people.


EXTRAORDINARY PEOPLE

Life stories of people who deserve to be known for who they were, what they did and what they stood for in their journey on earth.


ONE BY ONE

Stories of people whom a missionary met in his life and who were touched by Jesus in mysterious ways.


INCREASE OUR FAITH

Critical reflection from a Christian perspective on current issues.


SPECIAL MOMENTS

Comboni missionary Fr. Lorenzo Carraro makes a journey through history pinpointing landmark events that changed the course of humanity.


PROFILE

A biographical sketch of a public person, known for his/her influence in the society and in the Church, showing an exemplary commitment to the service of others.


WM REPORTS

Gives fresh, truthful, and comprehensive information on issues that are of concern to all.


LIFE'S ESSENTIALS

A column aimed at helping the readers live their Christian mission by focusing on what is essential in life and what it entails.


ASIAN FOCUS

Peoples, events, religion, culture and the society of Asia in focus.


THE SEARCHER'S PATH

The human heart always searches for greatness in God’s eyes, treading the path to the fullness of life - no matter what it takes.


INDIAN FOCUS

The subcontinent of India with its richness and variety of cultures and religions is given center stage.


AFRICAN FOCUS

The African continent in focus where Christianity is growing the fastest in the world.


JOURNEY MOMENTS

Well-known writer and public speaker, Fr. Jerry Orbos, accompanies our journey of life and faith with moments of wit and inspiration based on the biblical and human wisdom.


IGNATIUS STEPS

On the year dedicated to St. Ignatius of Loyala, Fr. Lorenzo Carraro walks us through the main themes of the Ignatian spirituality.


THE SEVEN LAST WORDS OF JESUS

Fr. John Taneburgo helps us to meditate every month on each of the Seven Last Words that Jesus uttered from the cross.


INSIDE THE HOLY BOOK

In this section, Fr. Lorenzo delves into the secrets and depths of the Sacred Scriptures opening for us the treasures of the Sacred Book so that the reader may delight in the knowledge of the Word of God.


CONVERSATIONS

Reflections about the synodal journey on a conversational and informal style to trigger reflection and sharing about the synodal path the Church has embarked upon.

Shopping Cart